How To Make Blender Nut Butter In 3 Easy Steps

How To Make Blender Nut Butter In 3 Easy Steps

When I first tried to learn how to make blender nut butter, I found myself in a sticky situation—literally.

I mean, who knew there was an art to this? But after many nutty experiments (and cleaning up more messes than I’d like to admit), I’ve found the sweet spot.

Whether you love almonds or peanuts, it’s amazing to see nuts turn into a creamy spread in just moments.

The key? A trusty high-speed blender that’s up to the job. If you’ve ever wondered how to make nut butter without breaking a sweat (or a blender), you’re in the right place. Stick with me, and I’ll show you how to whip up your very own jar in just 3 easy steps.

What is Homemade Blender Nut Butter?

Homemade nut butter is the process of grinding nuts into a creamy and delicious spread using simple tools like a blender or food processor.

Homemade nut butters have a fresh taste, free from additives, unlike some store-bought versions.

Think of it as the almond milk of spreads – natural, wholesome, and made right in the comfort of your own kitchen. Knowing what goes into your nut butter gives you both peace of mind and control over your ingredients.

Reasons You Need to Know How to Make Creamy Nut Butter at Home

Have you ever opened a jar of store-bought almond butter and found it too runny or just not tasting quite right? While store variants can be convenient, nothing quite matches the satisfaction and quality of making butter at home.

  • Control Over Texture: Say goodbye to too runny or too thick! Making it yourself means you get your ideal consistency every time.
  • No Additives: You control the ingredients, so there’s no unwanted stuff in your butter.
  • Freshness: Butter made at home is as fresh as it gets, ensuring the richest flavors.
  • Cost-Efficient: In the long run, sourcing your own nuts and making butter can be more cost-effective than always buying from the store.

Don’t settle for less. My method for creating the perfect creamy nut butter is simple and efficient and will guarantee you get the best spread every time you whip up a batch.

Making nut butter at home is transformative. The fresh taste and texture are unparalleled. A high-speed blender, like a Vitamix or a Ninja, is key for creamy results.

By the way, if you’re into shakes, check out my top protein shake blender picks! Once you’ve tried homemade, store-bought almond butter won’t compare. Dive in and savor the richness!

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Nut Butter At Home

After I followed this recipe once, every store-bought jar just seemed second best. Whether you’ve got a Ninja blender or a Vitamix blender by your side, this great recipe will guide you seamlessly.

  1. Nuts Selection & Roasting: Choose fresh nuts and give them a light roast for enhanced flavor.
  2. Blending Bonanza: Transfer the roasted nuts into your blender. Blend until you achieve a creamy consistency.
  3. Personal Touch: Enhance with a pinch of salt or a hint of honey for added flair. 

Excited? Let’s jump into the full tutorial and master the art of homemade nut butter.

Step 1. Nuts Selection & Roasting

First, choose which nuts you want to use for your homemade nut butter. Good options are raw almonds, peanuts, cashews, pecans, walnuts, or hazelnuts.

You can also use a mix of nuts like almond and walnut butter. Select unroasted nuts in their raw form for the best flavor.

Spread the nuts out on a pan or baking sheet and heat at 350°F, stirring often, until fragrant and amazing. Roasting enhances the incredible nutty flavor and is an important first step.

Step 2. Blending Bonanza

Next, transfer the perfectly roasted nuts to a powerful blender like a Vitamix, Ninja, or Blendtec. These professional blenders can finely grind even hard nuts into smooth, homemade nut butter.

Blend the nuts on high speed for 3-5 minutes, stopping to scrape down the sides, until completely creamy and smooth. You can add some coconut oil or avocado oil for smoother consistency.

Have patience and let the nut butter emulsify, as homemade always takes more time than store-bought.

Step 3. Personal Touch

Finally, customize your nut butter by mixing in sea salt, honey, cinnamon, cocoa powder, vanilla, or coconut. Swirl in Nutella, jam, or dark chocolate chips, too.

Get creative with different add-ins and flavors to make your own signature nut butter creations. The possibilities are endless when you make it yourself!

Key Considerations For Successfully Making Nut Butter

Using a high-powered blender like a Ninja Pro 1000 or a similar high-speed blender is essential for achieving the right consistency quickly. Regular blenders can work but require more effort and time.

The decision between making roasted or raw almond butter impacts the flavor. Roasting amplifies the almond’s depth and richness, while raw offers a milder profile.

Remember, homemade almond butter lacks the preservatives found in store-bought almond butter. Store in the refrigerator to maintain freshness and consume within a few weeks.

Taking it to the Next Level: How to Enhance Your Nut Butter Game

For those who’ve mastered the basics and want more, consider experimenting with mixed nut butter. Combining almonds with pecans or even throwing in a bit of coconut butter can elevate the texture and flavor.

For a gourmet touch, infuse your almond butter recipe with unique ingredients. Additions like a hint of coconut oil or sprinklings of almond flour can tweak the texture and taste, making your batch of almond butter stand out from the rest.

Lastly, if you’re curious about different flavors, explore recipes beyond almond. Pecan butter or a Nutella-inspired creation can be your next venture, broadening your nut butter repertoire and delighting your taste buds.

Alternatives to Making Nut Butter

If you’re without a high-powered blender or Vitamix, don’t fret. A food processor or blender of any kind can still yield great results, though it might take a tad longer. Patience, in this case, is your best friend. Regularly scraping down the sides ensures an even blend.

For those who’d rather not roast the almonds themselves but still want that roasted flavor, buying roasted almonds is a valid shortcut. Keep an eye on the label to ensure no additional oils or salts have been added if you’re looking for a pure experience.

And if DIY isn’t your thing, there are some fantastic store-bought almond butter options available. Brands that emphasize organic ingredients and no additives can often rival homemade versions in taste.

Be it almond butter from Trader Joe’s or another brand, it’s always good to have a backup when you’re not in the mood to make a batch at home.

Wrapping Up and My Experience With Making Nut Butter

Making nut butter at home has been a game-changer for me. From the first time I followed this recipe to the countless batches after, the difference in flavor and texture from store-bought almond butter is undeniable.

Using a high-speed blender, especially brands like Vitamix, has streamlined the process, ensuring creamy almond butter each time.

Through trial and error, I’ve discovered the best almond butter recipes, experimented with roasting techniques, and even dabbled in mixed nut butter concoctions. Trust me, once you try making it yourself, buying almond butter off the shelf just won’t feel the same.

I hope my insights and this amazing recipe guide you towards your perfect batch of nutty goodness. Enjoy every spoonful!


How can I make almond butter in a blender?

You can easily create almond butter at home using just a blender. Get the almond bag of raw almonds and roast them if you like the taste of roasted almond butter.

Once your almonds are ready, place them in a high-powered blender and blend until smooth. This can take a few minutes to make. Once it’s a creamy texture, you have homemade almond butter.

Is the process of making homemade almond butter worth the time and effort?

Absolutely. Homemade almond butter is usually healthier, tastier, and more economical than products like store-bought almond butter.

Plus, by making my almond butter at home, you know exactly what’s going into your food.

What are the key ingredients for making almond butter in a blender?

The key ingredient is just a bag of raw almonds. If you want, add a little bit of salt or a bit of honey to enhance the flavor.

Using a blender to make almond butter is not a very difficult task; it just requires patience.

Can I use roasted almonds for my homemade almond butter?

Yes, roasted almonds can be used, and they give a different recipe flavor compared to raw almonds.

Many people find that they make the best almond butter as roasting brings out the natural oils and gives the almond butter a Trader Joe’s-like flavor.

How long does it take to make almond butter in a blender?

Depending on the power of your blender, it may take between 10-30 minutes to make a smooth almond butter. The key to a creamy texture is patience and occasional scraping down of the blender sides.

I’d like to make almond butter at home. Should the almonds be soaked before blending?

This is definitely a matter of personal preference. Soaking almonds can help remove the almond skin and might make the blending process a bit smoother.

However, you can still achieve a creamy almond butter without soaking, it might just take a bit longer.

Can I make a huge batch of almond butter and store it?

Yes, you can make a large batch of almond butter and store it in an airtight container for up to 3 weeks.

Unlike store-bought jars of almond butter, homemade options do not contain any preservatives, so they should be consumed in a reasonable time.

Will almond butter turn out as smooth as peanut butter?

If made correctly, yes, you can achieve a smooth almond butter, much like the texture of peanut butter.

The key is to keep blending until you reach the consistency you desire. Using a high-powered blender will also result in a smoother consistency.

Can I use this almond butter to make recipes that call for peanut butter?

Sure, you can use almond butter instead of peanut butter in most recipes. Just bear in mind each butter would impart its own unique flavor to the dish.

I’ve made this recipe for almond butter, but I want to try a different recipe. Could I use a food processor instead?

Absolutely. Both high-powered blenders and food processors can be used to make homemade almond butter.

The process and result would be nearly the same, you would just need to adjust blending times accordingly.

Similar Posts